IR35 has two sets of rules. Under Chapter 8, which applies when your client is a small private-sector business or has no UK presence, your own company decides whether the contract is inside IR35 and pays the tax if it is. Under Chapter 10 (the off-payroll working rules), which applies to public sector clients and medium or large private-sector clients, the client decides, and whoever pays your company deducts tax and National Insurance first.
The status test is the same under both: would you be an employee if you worked for the client directly? What changes is who decides, who is liable if the decision is wrong, and how the tax is collected.
Written for contractors who work through their own limited company. General information for the 2026/27 tax year, not advice for your situation. IR35 status depends on the terms and working practices of each engagement, and nothing here decides whether a contract is inside or outside.
What is the difference between Chapter 8 and Chapter 10?
Both are chapters of Part 2 of the Income Tax (Earnings and Pensions) Act 2003. Chapter 8 is the original IR35 from 2000. Chapter 10 is the off-payroll working reform, which moved the decision to the client: for public sector clients from 6 April 2017, and for medium and large private-sector clients from 6 April 2021.
| Chapter 8 | Chapter 10 (off-payroll working) | |
|---|---|---|
| Applies when your client is | A small private-sector business, or overseas with no UK presence | In the public sector, or a medium or large private-sector business |
| Who decides your status | Your own company | The client, in a Status Determination Statement |
| Who is liable if inside | Your own company | The fee payer: the client or agency that pays your company. The client instead, if it didn't take reasonable care or didn't pass its decision on |
| How the tax is collected | Your company works out a deemed employment payment at the end of the tax year and pays the PAYE and National Insurance | The fee payer deducts income tax and employee's National Insurance from each payment, and pays employer's National Insurance on top |
| 5% expenses allowance | Yes | No |
| If you disagree | It's your decision, open to HMRC enquiry | You can challenge it with the client, who has 45 days to respond |
HMRC's guidance for contractors is at Understanding off-payroll working (IR35).
Which chapter applies to my contract?
It depends on the client, not on you:
- Public sector client: always Chapter 10, whatever its size.
- Medium or large private-sector client: Chapter 10.
- Small private-sector client: Chapter 8.
- Overseas client that isn't UK resident and has no permanent establishment here: Chapter 8, however large the client is. IR35 still applies; the decision and the liability are your company's.
A company is small if it meets at least two of three conditions: turnover of £15 million or less, a balance sheet total of £7.5 million or less, and 50 employees or fewer. For now, the previous limits of £10.2 million and £5.1 million still decide most contracts (see the box below). If the client is part of a group, the test is applied to the group as a whole, and different rules apply if the client isn't a company.
The £15 million and £7.5 million limits apply to financial years beginning on or after 6 April 2025 (before that they were £10.2 million and £5.1 million). A client's size for a tax year is based on an earlier financial year, and a company normally has to meet the test two years running before its status changes. HMRC's guidance (ESM10006A) says the earliest tax year the higher limits can affect a client is 2027/28, and depending on the client's year-end it can be later. So the old limits still decide 2026/27. Don't assume a client has become small: ask which rules it's applying to your contract for the current tax year.
What do I have to do under Chapter 8?
Your company has to decide, for each engagement, whether it's inside or outside IR35, based on how the work is actually done and not only on what the contract says. If it's inside, your company calculates a deemed employment payment at the end of the tax year: the income from that engagement, less a flat 5% for expenses and a few specific deductions, treated as salary paid on 5 April. Your company pays the income tax and National Insurance on it.
If you treat a contract as outside and HMRC later disagrees, your company owes the tax, with interest and possibly penalties. Keep the evidence behind your decision: the contract, a record of your working practices and any professional review.
What happens under Chapter 10?
The client must give you a Status Determination Statement (SDS) with its decision and its reasons, and must take reasonable care in reaching it. A blanket decision applied to every contractor without looking at each engagement isn't reasonable care.
If the SDS says inside, the fee payer treats your company's invoice (excluding VAT) like pay: it deducts income tax and employee's National Insurance, pays employer's National Insurance on top, and pays your company the rest. There's no 5% allowance.
Income that has already had tax deducted under Chapter 10 isn't taxed again in your company, and you can take it out as salary or dividends, up to the net amount your company received, without paying more income tax or National Insurance (HMRC ESM10035). It does need recording correctly in the company's payroll and accounts.
If you disagree with the SDS, tell the client, ideally in writing and with your reasons, before the last payment under the contract. The client has 45 days to reply, either confirming its decision with reasons or issuing a new one. If it doesn't reply in time, it becomes responsible for the tax until it does (HMRC ESM10015).
How is IR35 status decided?
There's no statutory checklist. The courts look at three things:
- Personal service. Are you required to do the work yourself? A real right to send a substitute, one the client would accept in practice, points away from employment.
- Control. Does the client have the right to control what you do, and how, when and where you do it?
- The overall picture. Taken together, do the arrangements look like a business serving a client or a person doing a job? Financial risk, your own equipment, other clients and how far you're part of the client's organisation all count.
No single factor decides it. One argument carries less weight than it used to: in September 2024 the Supreme Court held in PGMOL v HMRC [2024] UKSC 29 that the mutual obligations needed for employment can exist within a single engagement, so "the client doesn't have to offer me more work" is unlikely to settle the question. The overall picture still decides most cases: when that case went back to the tax tribunal, it found in May 2026 that the football referees involved were not employees.
HMRC's Check Employment Status for Tax (CEST) tool applies these tests. HMRC says it will stand by the result if the information entered is accurate and the tool is used in line with its guidance (ESM11010). The tool can also return "unable to determine".
What does being inside IR35 cost?
Less than the headline take-home comparison suggests, once every tax is counted on both sides. This example takes £100,000 of fees in 2026/27, with no expenses and no other income, and compares an outside contract with one that's inside under Chapter 8.
| On £100,000 of fees | Outside IR35 | Inside IR35 (Chapter 8) |
|---|---|---|
| Employer's National Insurance | £1,136 | £11,739 |
| Corporation tax | £19,118 | £950 |
| Income tax and employee's National Insurance | £0 | £24,412 |
| Dividend tax | £14,537 | £0 |
| Total tax | £34,790 | £37,101 |
| Take-home | £65,210 | £58,849 |
| Left in the company | £0 | £4,050 |
Outside: a £12,570 salary, with all the remaining profit drawn as dividends in the same year. Inside: the deemed employment payment after the 5% allowance, with employer's National Insurance at 15% above £5,000. 2026/27 rest-of-UK rates.
On these figures, being inside costs about £2,300 more in tax a year, not the £6,400 the take-home gap implies, because £4,050 stays in the company. In practice the gap is usually wider. Outside IR35 you choose when to draw profit, so you can keep dividends in the 10.75% band, as our salary vs dividends guide explains. Under Chapter 10 there's no 5% allowance, and the rate you're offered may be cut to cover the employer's National Insurance.
For take-home at £400 to £700 a day inside and outside IR35, see our contractor take-home pay guide.
What has changed recently?
- 6 April 2024: set-off. If HMRC decides a Chapter 10 engagement was wrongly treated as outside, the tax your company and you have already paid on that income can be set against the PAYE bill the client or fee payer faces (HMRC ESM10037). That lowers the cost of a wrong decision for clients, and removes one reason for blanket inside decisions.
- 6 April 2026: umbrella companies. Agencies, or the end client where there's no agency, are now jointly and severally liable for payroll taxes an umbrella company owes and doesn't pay (HMRC ESM2420). This doesn't apply to your own company, but it affects which umbrellas an agency will offer you for an inside-IR35 contract.
- 14 October 2026: employment status consultation. The government is consulting on reforming employment status until 8 January 2027. Nothing has changed yet, and the Budget on 28 October 2026 didn't change the off-payroll rules.
- From 2027/28 at the earliest: the higher size limits start to bring more clients into the small category, and so more contracts under Chapter 8.
Can my accountant tell me I'm outside IR35?
Not on their own, and that includes us. We can explain which chapter applies, show what an inside or outside decision does to your take-home, and make sure deducted income is treated correctly in your payroll, accounts and tax return. We don't review contracts or give status opinions. For a formal view on a contract and your working practices, we refer you to a specialist contract reviewer.
Common questions
Does IR35 apply if my client is overseas?
Yes. If the client isn't UK resident and has no permanent establishment in the UK, Chapter 10 doesn't apply, so the contract falls under Chapter 8: your own company decides its status and is liable for the tax if it's inside.
Who is the fee payer under Chapter 10?
The business that pays your company: the agency if you work through one, or the client if you contract directly. The fee payer deducts the tax and National Insurance and pays them to HMRC.
Is a CEST result binding on HMRC?
HMRC says it will stand by a CEST result provided the information entered was accurate and the tool was used in line with its guidance. A result based on the contract wording alone, where the working practices differ, doesn't protect anyone.
Do the higher small company limits mean my contract moves to Chapter 8?
Possibly, but not before the 2027/28 tax year, and later for some clients, because a client's size is based on an earlier financial year. Ask the client which rules it's applying for the current tax year.
Related guides
- Contractor take-home pay 2026/27: day rates inside and outside IR35.
- Salary vs dividends 2026/27: how to draw profit from an outside-IR35 contract.
- Contractor expenses: what your company can claim.
- Frequently asked questions: short answers on IR35, VAT and switching accountant.
Want to see what IR35 does to your numbers?
Practical IR35 guidance is part of our Standard and Premium packages: which rules apply to your contract, what a decision means for your take-home, and a referral to a specialist reviewer when you need a formal opinion.
Book a call →